Don's Blog

Clay Shaw/Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw/Dueling Voices/I Lost It at the Beginning/101 Reasons Not To Murder The Entire Saudi Royal Family/He Knew Where He Was Going (?)

Thursday, April 28, 2022

Slowing Interest in the Jim Garrison Investigation?

 Over the years since 1967-69, when interest in what came to be known as the Jim Garrison Investigation, the high point of which was the arrest, trial, and prosecution of Clay Shaw, was at its peak, the case has vanished completely from the news and been resurrected several times. The two year period between arrest and trial was very intense, but after the acquittal of Clay Shaw, interest diminished quickly, even though during the 1969-71 period. Shaw was re-arrested on perjury charges two days after his acquittal, and that case limped along for two years before a Federal court prohibited any further prosecution. Shaw filed an a civil suit against Garrison and others, and it, too, progressed very slowly, seeming to pick up steam only shortly before Shaw's death in 1974. It was quite a tangled mess, one that I explain in much detail in the context of Shaw's life in my biography of him, Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw.

Now, 55 years after it all began, I sensed a diminished interest in Shaw, even among conspiracy theorists. Since Shaw was the only person ever tried for the assassination, it was natural that many would cling to him as a suspect or person of interest. Even if he wasn't technically guilty, many said, he must have known Oswald, must have shepherded him around New Orleans. And Shaw surely knew David Ferrie, the somewhat strange, shadowy man also allegedly present at the all-important "party" or meeting where the assassination was discussed.

I haven't seen the recent Oliver Stone documentary about the assassination, but my understanding is that there is very little mention of Shaw, perhaps more of Garrison (but not as much as in Stone's 1991 movie JFK.

What does it all mean? Does it signify that the Garrison case and any suspicions of Shaw are dying out? Or is it a temporary resting point, as has happened in the past? There are reasons for believing that this time, it might be different. But I don't think so.

Labels: ,

Friday, April 22, 2022

Clay Shaw and Alfred J. Moran

Alfred J. Moran figured somewhat prominently (but behind the scenes) in the evidence presented against Clay Shaw at Shaw's trial. As I explain in some detail in my biography of Clay Shaw, Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, Alfred Moran dropped some information at a social gathering in the fall of 1967, after Shaw's initial trial date had been postponed. The trial was reschedule to begin in about four or five months, and it was during this period that the evidence of Shaw's supposed visit to the Eastern Airlines VIP room, where he allegedly signed the guest register using the name "Clay Bertrand," was being developed. Alfred Moran had been present in the VIP Room on the date in question, and the information he gave was consistent. However, it was garbled in a series of CIA memos (a CIA employee who knew Moran had been present at the social gathering where Moran discussed his knowledge of the event. Confusion about the nature of that information caused noticeable confusion at the CIA for a period.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, April 20, 2022

Clay Shaw and Richard Townley

One of the journalists who figures prominently in the first six months of the period before and after Clay Shaw's arrest was Richard Townley, an investigative reporter for WDSU-TV in New Orleans. I e-mailed with Richard, interviewed him by telephone, and then drove to his residence in Mountain Home, Arkansas during the middle part of 2007. Richard provided quite a lot of useful information, about which I reported in my biography of Clay Shaw, entitled Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw.

Richard was alerted to the Garrison investigation before news of it broke on February 17, 1967, and certain information he received from inside of Garrison's office convinced him that it was an invalid investigation from the start. He was eventually indicted by Garrison, and found it necessary to seek employment outside of New Orleans. I give a detailed account of this in my book.

I found Richard credible. He was forthright about things that went on, and he was very candid about his investigative "partner", Walter Sheridan, a former key aide to Robert Kennedy and, at the time of Garrison's investigation, an investigative reporter for NBC News.

Richard passed in early 2009, way too young, after several long-term health issues.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, December 22, 2020

New Interest in Clay Shaw

 I sense a new interest in Clay Shaw, beyond just his prosecution. I felt I made a very good attempt to answer as many questions as I could, but as with any person's life, there were still unanswered questions at the end of my exhaustive search.

As time rolls by, I'll be curious if someone is able to discover some letter, telegram, diary, etc., that sheds some light on the remaining mysteries.

https://www.amazon.com/Man-Million-Fragments-True-Story-ebook/dp/B00D2XYSGY/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=clay+shaw&qid=1608645569&sr=8-1

Labels: ,

Tuesday, June 16, 2020

Clay Shaw's Return to New Orleans In Early 1942

One of the minor mysteries about Clay Shaw is his return to New Orleans in early 1942 (or possibly earlier), where he worked for a company that was managed or owned by Theodore Brent and Rudolf Hecht.

Until I discovered that in the Norman Cousins papers, I was always under the impression that Shaw went to New York City in early 1936 and only returned to work after the war had ended. However, this evidence showed that he was working for this company that apparently had something to do with manufacturing aircraft and possibly other wartime industry materials. Shaw and Cousins communicated during this period, and I believe that Cousins even visited with Shaw at his apartment in New Orleans.

Shaw apparently returned to New York City later in 1942, and had some discussion with Norman Cousins about working for seemed to be some type of arts-related wartime effort (which presumably would have kept him out of the military). However, that apparently never panned out and Shaw went on into the military and eventually overseas.

The discovery of this information did give at least partial answers to two questions:

1. How did Shaw get the job at the International Trade Mart (ITM) immediately upon getting out of the military in early 1946. He had worked for Brent and Hecht, the two leading figures at both ITM and International House (IH) in New Orleans immediately prior to going into the military. I'm sure he had known them before that as well. Little of Brent and Hecht's records or correspondence has survived to my knowledge, other than a fair amount in the ITM and IH records, which are helpful but not 100% complete.

2. Shaw had been friends with Kay Lucas (later Kay Lucas Leake Dart) from his work in the theater in New Orleans, and I think he may have seen her in New York as well. In a 1967 letter, in what I interpreted as an oblique reference to Shaw's homosexuality, Kay Lucas Leake Dart mentioned a "long, long night at 727 St. Ann" where they tried the "Noble Experiment." I assumed from that it was a reference to an attempt to have physical relations, but could never figure out when Shaw lived at 727 St. Ann, or when Kay Lucas Leake Dart did. However, in the letters to and from Norman Cousins during this early 1942 period, Shaw used the address of 727 St. Ann.

Still, mystery abounds on those gaps in the Clay Shaw story, and some things may take more independent research before being cleared up, if indeed they can.

Labels: , ,

Monday, November 11, 2019

Clay Shaw: 2019 Gulf South HIstory and Humanities Conference in Pensacola, Florida

I recently appeared on a panel with Dr. Alecia Long of LSU and Fred Litwin at the Gulf South History and Humanities Conference in Pensacola. Alecia spoke on attitudes reflected toward gays in memos written at the CIA, FBI, and other government agencies during the period prior to and during the Jim Garrison investigation. Fred spoke in quite a bit of detail on the Permindex/CMC aspects of the Clay Shaw arrest and prosecution. I was, more or less, the moderator and general commentator of the panel.

The audience, while small, seemed quite engaged about the topic(s). I was very encouraged that others are really digging deep on the many topics raised by Jim Garrison's investigation and prosecution of Clay Shaw. I had touched on both gay issues generally and Permindex/CMC in my biography of Clay Shaw, Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, but it was more appropriate to deal with those in detail in individual presentations. Alecia and Fred set a high standard with their research, such that, by the time they had finished, the topics seemed settled. I was very impressed.

Labels:

Sunday, July 1, 2018

Clay Shaw Biography Still Selling

Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, still selling. The sales ebb and flow with big news bursts related to the JFK Assassination. Additionally, I continue to hear from individuals in far-flung areas who knew Clay Shaw, or knew someone who knew him.

Most of the contacts in the time since the book came out were people who knew him socially in some way, prior to his involvement in the Jim Garrison investigation. He knew a fascinating mix of people, and those who have passed often left behind their memories of him in some way.

Labels: , , , , ,

Tuesday, January 9, 2018

Wikipedia Entry for Clay Shaw

I was just reading through the Wikipedia entry for Clay Shaw, which seems woefully inadequate, considering his importance to New Orleans during a critical time, and also to the body of JFK assassination theory and history. This may be a case where the story, and his life story are so complex, whether in actuality or fictionally, that it cannot be captured properly in an encyclopedia entry.

It's true that the nuances of Shaw's life, the Jim Garrison investigation, and the Kennedy assassination in general do not lend themselves easily to simple explanations. I do not, however, that the Wikipedia article does not really give a solid list of sources for further reading, places the entry reader may go to find out the most complete set of details that can be put together about Shaw, his activities, and his role in the assassination.

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Monday, November 20, 2017

William Zetzmann and Clay Shaw

In my Clay Shaw bio, Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, I include a lot of references to William Zetzmann. He was a very prominent civic leader who owned, among other interests, a soft drink bottling company. In my youth, I drank many a 7-Up and a few Big Oranges bottled by the Zetz Bottling Company.

Zetzmann was involved in the proposed international fair proposed very early in World War II for New Orleans, a Pan American style fair that, I believe, never came to be. However, it segued into what was to be known as International House, and the International Trade Mart. The INternational Trade Mart was managed by Clay Shaw from early 1946, essentially the beginning of promotion some two and a half years before it opened, through September 1965.

Zetzmann became the President of the International Trade Mart around June 1953, shortly after the death of founding President Theodore Brent. He would serve as President until his death in 1962, and was effectively Clay Shaw's boss during that time period. He seemed to have entered the job having complete confidence in Shaw, having already observed the job he did from his position on the board of directors. He seemed to give Shaw free rein to carry out the mission of the Mart. Of course, the Mart declined severely during this period, as there was a multi-year period during which plans for a new Mart building came and went and returned, various potential building sites were explored and abandoned, financing was proposed and fell through, and existing tenants left in greater and greater numbers. Also during this period, the close relationship between the International Trade Mart and International House fractured severely. There were many reasons for all this.

Zetzmann's death would usher in Lloyd Cobb as the President of the International Trade Mart. I will discuss Cobb in a later post.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Sunday, October 15, 2017

Clay Shaw and Rudolf Hecht

Some readers of my biography of Clay Shaw, Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, have asked about Rudolf Hecht and his relationship with Clay Shaw.

There is much about Hecht in the book, including his very active role on the Boards of Directors of both the International Trade Mart and International House from their inception until his death in early 1956. Hecht made a fortune in banking and shipping, and was well set when Shaw went to work under his supervision.

It is unclear exactly how he and Shaw first met, but Shaw worked for him as early as the spring of 1942, not long before going into the Army. Hecht and Theodore Brent were involved in a wartime shipping company, somewhat separate from the Mississippi Shipping Company, the main shipping company upon whose board both men sat.

Hecht seem to stay a bit behind the scenes in both International House and International Trade Mart, but was very active in decision-making. It is fair to say that nothing major was done without his approval.

While outside of the scope of my book, Hecht apparently was involved in some banking shenanigans leading into the Great Depression or coming out of it. He seemed to have escaped responsibility for many losing their savings, or at least such allegations were made. In one FBI memo I saw, it was said that in the 1930s, the FBI had recommended that Hecht be arrested and indicted for bank fraud, but that the local Federal attorney in New Orleans had shot the recommendation down.

Hecht was known for his world travels and the travelogues he wrote during those trips. In the 1940s, for instance, he made major trips to Africa, Asia, South America, country by country, all corners of the globe. He gave copies of each travelogue to Clay Shaw to read after Hecht returned from each trip. Once, Shaw wrote to him in a memo that he lived "vicariously" through Hecht's writings about such trips.

Hecht is largely forgotten today in New Orleans, like many around International Trade Mart and International House, but he was widely respected in the NOLA business world for most of the first half of last century.

Labels: , , , , ,

Wednesday, August 23, 2017

Clay Shaw and Theodore Brent

Some readers of my biography of Clay Shaw, Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, have asked about Theodore Brent and his relationship with Clay Shaw.

There is much about Brent in the book, including his very active role as first President of the International Trade Mart from its inception into mid-1953. Brent came from a modest background, but in the rail and shipping industries, became a millionaire back when that meant being very wealthy. His estate in 1953 was valued at over $2 million.

It is unclear exactly how he and Shaw first met, but it was around 1930 or 1931, probably through Shaw's employment at Western Union (my speculation). It is also unclear how much of a mentor he was to Shaw, but he was clearly an important figure in Shaw's life. He left Shaw about $2,000 in his will (much less than Jim Garrison and others apparently thought), but he left other individuals much more. For instance, Shaw's assistant, J.B. Dauenhauer, received $5,000.

Brent is largely forgotten today in New Orleans, but he was widely respected in the NOLA business world for most of the first half of last century.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Wednesday, July 19, 2017

Clay Shaw Bio Marches On!

I continue to hear good feedback about the biography of Clay Shaw, Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw. I have recently heard from several readers who were just discovering the book. Each knew one or more of the individuals who were friends or acquaintances of Clay Shaw, especially during the 1950s, around the International Trade Mart and International House. In general, they felt that the book had captured the spirit of that bygone era.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Saturday, December 3, 2016

What Did The International Trade Mart Under Clay Shaw Do?

In my biography of Clay Shaw, Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, I go into great detail on the origin of the International Trade Mart, its intended purpose, its activities, its ups and downs over the years, and Clay Shaw's part in them.

The International Trade Mart was part of a quite unified city-wide effort to increase trade through the Port of New Orleans. International House, its sister organization, was also an important part of that, as was the Free Trade Zone, where shippers could send goods that could escape tariffs, if only temporarily in some cases. The City of New Orleans government agencies were involved as well, as were the Chamber of Commerce, major shipping lines, and other large business entities.

It could appear to an outsider as if the International Trade Mart had a murkier side, and of course that comes up frequently in any discussion of Clay Shaw. The book outlines what he did, and what the Mart did. It is ultimately up to the reader to draw his or her own conclusion.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Wednesday, September 7, 2016

Was Clay Shaw Compensated by the CIA?

Steve M. Galbraith wrote in with a comment back a few months ago and it was never forwarded directly to me. My apologies, Steve!

Actually, Steve had a question about whether Clay Shaw was ever compensated for his interaction with the CIA from 1948-56. I call them interactions rather than services because, based upon my own investigation, his interactions with them appeared to be very limited, essentially passing on to the CIA very sketchy and borderline unimportant fragments of information.

However, two sources, with links immediately below, show that the CIA apparently told the House Select Committee on Assassinations (HSCA), back in the late 1970s, that he was never compensated, and then, in 1992, put together an internal memo saying that he had been a highly-paid source.

https://www.maryferrell.org/showDoc.html?docId=7302&relPageId=3,
https://www.maryferrell.org/showDoc.html

Steve asked if I had resolved that contradiction in my biography of Clay Shaw, Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw. The short answer is NO, in the sense that I never determined why the CIA had phrased in the 1992 internal memo as it did. The writer of that memo seemed to be reviewing the material that the CIA had furnished to the HSCA in the 1970s, in preparation for the CIA's cooperation with the Assassination Records Review Board (ARRB). However, none of that material provided to HSCA by the CIA in the 1970s indicated in any way that the CIA had ever compensated Shaw. Quite the opposite: the CIA, in the briefest of assertions to the HSCA, said that it had never given him any compensation.

I tend to believe that he received no compensation, based upon what has been revealed to date about the nature of his interactions with the CIA. His information was very limited, almost useless, and what little of substance he gave to them peaked early on, after his 1949 trip to the Caribbean, Central America, and northern South America, and his 1951 trip to southern South America.

My speculation is that a CIA staffer who put the 1992 memo together for internal historian J. Kenneth McDonald simply got that detail incorrect. I have a FOIA request to CIA on that very detail, asking them to provide any details of any compensation, but that could take years to resolve, if the CIA even cooperates. Many would consider it an open question, and I have no problem with that.

Steve Galbraith also asked if Shaw ever underwent a background investigation prior to his interactions with the CIA back in late 1948 or early 1949, and whether the CIA was aware of Shaw's homosexuality. I don't know if the CIA did an official background investigation. One memo I saw seemed to indicate that the CIA relied on a background check that had already been done by other government agencies (or perhaps one agency). That agency could very weel have been the FBI, which interviewed Shaw in late 1948 at the time that the Czech Trade Exhibit signed a lease with the International Trade Mart. The lease would began the following spring (195) and run for one year, after which it was not renewed. The FBI was very interested in this, and interviewed Shaw about it it. I have always suspected that this led to the CIA's local office, which had recently opened, deciding to use Shaw, among others, as a source of information about international goings-on in New Orleans and the places he traveled. The FBI knew much about Shaw's homosexuality by 1954, and probably much earlier, so I suspect that information was passed on the CIA in the same time period.

The end of Shaw's limited relationship with the CIA in 1956 appeared to have nothing to do with his homosexuality. Instead, he simply had ceased traveling internationally (he would only travel to Cuba, very briefly, and to Puerto Rico for a special project, after 1955, on behalf of the ITM), the ITM was beginning its downward spiral, and he was busier than ever with his real estate projects and social activities. His information had always been limited, centered around his trips on behalf of the ITM, and that activity had by this time all dried up.

Labels: , , , ,

Friday, April 1, 2016

Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw

In my biography of Clay Shaw, entitled Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, I discussed Shaw's life from start to finish in broad detail. The Jim Garrison investigation is largely considered to be discredited, although it has been resurrected here and there over the years.

However, it is still quite surprising how often Clay Shaw's name still comes up in conspiracy theories. Even among those who dismiss Jim Garrison's investigation overall, there seems still to be an underlying belief that Shaw must have had some involvement, however mysterious and unresolved, either in the assassination, or in "handling" Oswald during his time back in the United States after his return from the Soviet Union. The feeling is there, if the facts are often murky or missing.

My book should give the broadest possible canvas for those researching any role Shaw may have had, as it details numerous sources never before developed or written about. It can clearly be used in both directions, and has been.

Labels: , , , , ,

Tuesday, February 16, 2016

Clay Shaw and Ruth Branigan

Even with the publication of my biography of Clay Shaw, Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, there remain a few unresolved questions. Clay Shaw was the only person ever prosecuted for alleged involvement in the JFK assassination.

One involves Ruth Branigan, who in the 1960s was in the Department of Merchandising at Old Dominion College (now Old Dominion University) in Norfolk, Virginia. I believe that she might have been a faculty member, but am not certain of that.

Although I spent some time on an attempt to flesh out the relationship, as I did with all of Shaw's friends and acquaintances, I never figured out how she and Clay Shaw knew each other, when they first met, or the extent of their friendship (she was obviously supportive of him after his acquittal).

If anyone knew or knows of this Ruth Branigan, please contact me by telephone, letter, or e-mail.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, had a nice 2015

Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, a biography of the only man ever prosecuted for alleged involvement in the assassination of President Kennedy, has just finished a nice 2015. It was the first full year that a print edition has been available, and had good sales, buiding on the first two years when only the e-book was available.

It garnered some notable reviews, generally split along conspiracy (or the lack thereof) theory lines of thought. Any book on the assassination is bound to have that split, with two large hostile camps already in place for decades, so this was to be expected.

And, of course, it has had to find its audience, always challenging in this day when readers are bombarded with material from all sides and in all forms. But it is steadily working its way around the horn, so to speak.

Here's to an even better 2016!

Labels: , , , , , ,

Sunday, May 3, 2015

Man Of A Million Fragments: The True Story Of Clay Shaw, A Biography Of Clay Shaw, Doing Quite Well

Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, my full-length biography of Clay Shaw, is doing very well. It has been clawing its way up from ground zero, and March was one of its best month since the e-book first appeared in late May 2013. The print edition came out in late July, 2014, and added a new dimension to its availability.

It generated some new favorable reviews this year, and continues to generate excellent reviews from those who really know anything about Clay Shaw and his era, the city of New Orleans and the international trade effort there in the 1940s through the 1970s.

Of course, it tends to generate negative buzz from those who object to some of its contents, even tiny portions of the book, and its overall conclusions, such as they are, but that is fair as well. No one who undertakes a project dealing with Clay Shaw can ever expect to have 100% positive response. but overall, it continues to find its audience, with a minimum of publicity and a maximum of good word of mouth.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Thursday, January 22, 2015

John Seigenthaler's FBI File Released

The FBI has notified me, in response to my Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request, that it has now released John Seigenthaler's FBI file on its website. I have a separate request in, and have appealed the adequacy of the FBI's search.

I became interested in John Seigenthaler's file as a result of my research into the life of Clay Shaw, which culminated in a major biography of Shaw, entitled Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, published in 2013 as an e-book and last year in a print edition.

The book detailed John Seigenthaler's involvement behind the scenes in an effort to obtain internal documents from New Orleans District Attorney Jim Garrison's investigation in 1967 into the assassination of President Kennedy. An insider in Garrison's investigation, William Gurvich gave the documents to longtime Bobby Kennedy aide Walter Sheridan, who then got them in one fashion or another to Seigenthaler and the Tennessean newspaper for its reporting.

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Monday, January 19, 2015

Court Activity Related to Clay Shaw Prosecution and Civil Suit

The prosecution of Clay Shaw, and his later civil suit against New Orleans Jim Garrison and others, generated quite a bit of court activity during the period from March 1967 through May 1978. As I detail in my biography of Clay Shaw, Man of a Million Fragments: The True Story of Clay Shaw, Shaw's attorneys, led by Irvin Dymond and Edward Wegmann, first attempted to avoid prosecution for Clay Shaw altogether. They raised objections over the vagueness of the charges, the venue where the case would be tried, the selection of the jury and the pool from which it would be selected, and other things. Once those moves had been heard through the Louisiana state court system, they moved to Federal District Court in an attempt to prove that Clay Shaw's civil rights were being violated. Those issues were litigated up through the appellate courts until the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear Shaw's appeal.

After the case was tried, and Shaw found not guilty, Shaw was charged with perjury for his testimony during the trial. Almost two years later, Shaw attorneys, after litigating the new charges through the state court system, returned to Federal Court in a new attempt to show that Shaw's civil right had been violated. This time, a Federal district judge ruled that the continuing prosecution was essentially in bad faith, and otder that the prosecution not continue. His ruling was then litigated up the Federal court system until the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear it, and the dkistrict judge's ruling stood.

Meanwhile, Clay Shaw's civil suit against Jim Garrison for wrongful prosecution, begun in 1970, continued up through the Federal courts. Key issues had to be decided: could the suit against District Attorney Jim Garrison even proceed? Could the suit continue after Shaw's death?

A full discussion of these complex issues and decisions, many of which are still relevant today, are contained in the bio.

Labels: , , , , , , ,